After Infidelity: Which Pattern Do You Fall Into?

Your partner has committed adultery. Possibly the worst betrayal you can imagine. Your marriage is in deep distress and you are rocked to your core. Your partner says he’s sorry, but it isn’t enough. You both decide counseling is in order and you spend a few weeks or months in therapy trying to weather the crisis. You know you have to rebuild trust in your relationship, try to forgive, and begin to be a couple again. Essentially, you have to reboot your relationship.

Some couples survive this crisis better than others. Some even thrive. Basically, it depends on how well you can get past the trauma of infidelity. Once you do, your marriage will probably fall into one of thee patterns.

After Infidelity: Which Pattern Do You Fall Into? Nancy'S Counseling Corner

1) Picking the Scab. There are people who just can’t move forward. They are so hurt that even months or years later they think of yet another aspect of how aggrieved they are. They continue to replay that sad tape over and over in their heads. Their bitterness knows no bounds.

And their partners—even if they committed the adultery—contribute with their own recriminations. “If you were more responsive I wouldn’t have had to go somewhere else for sex,” is a good example. Some people decide to remain together, yet forever pick the scab of the wound, ensuring it will never heal.

Sometimes the wounded party takes the moral high ground, using her hurt to feel superior to her partner. This constant reminder that he is flawed and committed a sin against her is her consolation, but it never allows the wound to heal. In fact, while it may provide temporary solace, it’s an attitude that guarantees long-term unhappiness.

Making love is a perfect bonding experience, yet sex is sometimes difficult. “If I had sex with him, all I would be able to think of would be him with another partner. Did he do the same things with her? Did he have the same expressions? Did he enjoy it more with her than me?” Another problem with post adultery sex is that it signals that all is well between partners when all is not yet well. “I can’t have sex with him because he would think everything is okay. That he can have sex with someone else and then turn around and have sex with me. It’s like giving him the stamp of approval, and I can’t do that.”

2) Soldiering On. Some people want to get back to the way life was before infidelity. They try to smooth things over. They just keep on keeping on because they can’t devise a better solution. Maybe addressing the situation directly is just too painful—many people avoid confrontation like the Plague. Maybe they have a perfunctory talk without truly understanding the root causes of the affair, or making any improvements in their relationship. These couples move past infidelity, but nothing assures them that another affair won’t happen. Their marriages are not changed for the better—they just continue on as things were. They maintain a peaceful, if fragile, truce.

3) Reinventing the Relationship. The most successful couples navigate the turmoil and finally come to a point where they can think about their relationship differently. Because it will never be the same. But it could, with some soul searching, become even better. These are couples who have experienced remorse. The party who strayed is truly sorry and demonstrates it often. The aggrieved party finds it in her heart to forgive. Enough time passes for the hurt and anger to subside. They begin to think of themselves as a couple again. And they think of the infidelity as something that happened to both of them. A crisis that they weathered together.

Couples who have a second chance at reinventing themselves have found a way to trust again. They look upon the experience as one that is shared—it happened to them both. And now they are working together to rewrite their lives—to reinvent a new way to be together. They’ve learned from their experience and going forward they are going to be better than ever.

 

Nancy Travers is an Orange County Counseling professional. If you need safe, effective counseling services, please get in touch. You can reach her here: https://nancyscounselingcorner.com/contact

 

 

If you found this post helpful, you might also enjoy exploring some of our other articles that dive deeper into the topics of relationships, communication, and emotional wellness. Whether you’re looking to strengthen your current connection, better understand co-dependency, or prepare for a healthy marriage, these related posts offer valuable insights and tools to support your journey. Take a look—you may find just what you need.

Related Posts

How Women Are Silently Quitting Their Marriages

In many relationships, disconnection doesn’t begin with a dramatic argument or a sudden breakup. Instead, it often starts quietly. More and more marriage counselors are seeing a pattern where women emotionally withdraw from their marriages long before separation or divorce is discussed. This experience is sometimes described as “silently quitting” a marriage, where effort, emotional investment, and hope slowly fade without outward conflict. What “Silently Quitting” a Marriage Looks Like

Read More »

Resolve to Forgive Yourself in 2026

We all know that forgiveness is good for the soul. It frees us from the bitterness and anger that accompany us throughout our days and dog us with sleepless nights. We all know there are often times when it’s hard to forgive. That’s when we need to remember that forgiveness is actually a gift to ourselves, and the best gift of all is being able to forgive the most difficult

Read More »

New Year Resolutions and Your Relationships

As a new year begins, many people set resolutions focused on self-improvement—better habits, clearer goals, or renewed motivation. When viewed through a relational lens, resolutions can also become powerful opportunities to shift long-standing patterns in our relationships. Rather than striving to change others or perfect ourselves, relational resolutions invite us to practice greater awareness, honesty, and self-respect in how we connect. For those impacted by shame or codependency, New Year

Read More »
RELATIONSHIP COUNSELING SERVICES

Find The Counseling Service That Is Right For You

At Nancy’s Counseling Corner, we’re here to support every stage of your relationship journey. Whether you’re navigating challenges in your marriage, preparing for lifelong commitment through premarital counseling, or working through the emotions of separation and divorce, our services are designed with care, compassion, and expertise. We specialize in Marriage Counseling, Relationship Counseling, Premarital Counseling, Divorce Counseling, Co-dependency Counseling—and so much more. No matter where you are, healing and growth are possible. Let’s take that next step—together.

Marriage & Couples Counseling

Marriage is a lifelong commitment that requires hard work, love, care, and understanding the needs of other people.

Relationship Counseling

Can help you find–and keep–the love of your life. Relationships are challenging and require an extensive amount of patience.

Divorce Counseling

Divorce Counseling is an emotional and strenuous thought for those seeking to solve marital problems.

Depression Counseling

Depression is a mental disorder characterized by at least 10-14 days of noticeable or recognizable low mood.

Co-dependency

“Codependency” is a term we hear thrown around a lot these days, though many of us aren’t sure exactly what it means.

Premarital Counseling

Offers Premarital Counseling to couples in the Orange County area that are considering to get married or are already engaged.

Anxiety Counseling

Offers Premarital Counseling to couples in the Orange County area that are considering to get married or are already engaged.

Meditation

Offers Premarital Counseling to couples in the Orange County area that are considering to get married or are already engaged.

Hypnosis

Offers Premarital Counseling to couples in the Orange County area that are considering to get married or are already engaged.